How Has NPS Performed in Comparison with Other Retirement Instruments?

Buy a Life Insurance Plan in a few clicks

Now you can buy life insurance plan online.

Kotak e-Term Plan

Protect Your family’s financial future with Kotak e-Term Plan. Know more

Kotak Assured Savings Plan

A plan that offer guaranteed returns and financial protection for your family. Know more

Kotak Guaranteed Savings Plan

A plan that offers long term savings and insurance in one premium. Know more

Kotak e-Invest

Insurance and investment in one plan with Kotak e-Invest. Know more

Kotak Health Shield

Insurance against medical expenses related to heart, brain, liver and Cancer. Know more

How Has NPS Performed in Comparison with Other Instruments?

How Has NPS Performed in Comparison with Other Instruments?
  • 13th Jun 2022 |
  • 3,886

The desire for a financially secure and comfortable post-retirement life is what makes you invest your money in schemes that will help protect these dreams. That corpus serves as a critical backbone for those golden years of your life. This also introduces you to a host of financial plans that are often surrounded by a calculated mix of expenditures and savings. With so many investment instruments around in the financial framework, choosing the one that can deliver maximum value for your money becomes challenging. While the National Pension System (NPS) is one of the most popular investment choices, there are various concerns and questions regarding it.

In this article, we will learn about the pros and cons of NPS and compare it to other investment options so that you can make an informed decision that caters to all your requirements.

The Basics of the National Pension Scheme

National Pension Scheme is a government-run social security programme. Except for military personnel, this pension scheme is available to all public, private, and unorganized employees. As part of the system, employees are urged to contribute to a pension fund at regular intervals throughout their employment. Contributors can withdraw a fixed amount of money from the account when they retire. If you have an NPS account, you will get the leftover money as a monthly allowance once you retire.

Advantages of NPS

Following are some of the most valued advantages of NPS:

  • Diversification is one of the essential NPS plan advantages as it allows you to engage in both the equity and debt markets with a single transaction.
  • Section 80CCE (Sub-section of Section 80C) of the Finance Bill 2011-12 allows for a tax deduction on contributions made by an employer to an employee’s national pension programme (NPS) account of up to 10% of basic pay and dearness allowance (DA).
  • You can now apply for NPS accounts online at the most accredited banks. To apply for NPS, you must submit a completed registration form, evidence of address, proof of identification, and certificate of birth.

Disadvantages of NPS

Below mentioned are some drawbacks of NPS:

  • There is some ambiguity regarding the withdrawal of taxes, which is why most users question, “Is NPS return guaranteed?”. Under current laws, about 60% of the corpus can be removed at maturity. In comparison, at least 40% must be utilized to purchase annuities and annuity insurance plan returns are currently not tax-free.
  • NPS portfolios are not allowed to contain more than 50% equity investment. For those in their 20s and early 30s, it means losing money since equity has demonstrated to provide 12-15% annual returns over extended periods of time.
  • You may modify your investment strategy between government securities, corporate bonds, and equities. However, the equity exposure is limited to a particular percentage. Many investors seeking better returns consider this a significant disadvantage of NPS.


Public Provident Fund (PPF) has a holding period option that offers a marketable interest rate and investment returns. Under the Income Tax Act, profits and returns are not taxable. The maturity duration of a PPF account is 15 years. The risks are low because PPF invests entirely in debt. Each quarter, the government sets the interest rate, which remains unchanged for that quarter. On the other hand, returns from NPS aren’t guaranteed and are subject to market factors.

Mutual Funds vs NPS

Mutual funds are a collection of many diverse investment options that create returns over a considerable length of time. AMCs engage experienced experts known as fund managers to meticulously handle clients’ funds and adjust allocations in response to market movements. Because of the flexibility (you have the option of withdrawing your funds) they provide, mutual funds are frequently used as emergency savings. As a result, it is recommended to invest in NPS if your objective is to retire with tax advantages and you have a low-risk appetite.


Equity Linked Savings Scheme (ELSS) is a form of diversified equity programme offered by mutual funds in India with a three-year lock-in period. Because ELSS is entirely equity-oriented, it is significantly riskier than NPS. The highest equity allotment in NPS is set at 75%, enabling you to invest in typically safe asset groups, such as corporate bonds and government securities.

The financial market brings numerous alternatives for you to choose from. Having understood the pros and cons of NPS, you can now make a prudent decision. Keep in mind that while choosing an investment opportunity, you must ensure that you choose one that aligns well with your needs and risk appetite. Only after conducting comprehensive research should you settle for an option!

Kotak e-Invest

In this policy, the investment risk in the investment portfolio is borne by the policyholder.

Download Brochure


  • Return of Mortality Charges*$
  • Enhanced Protection
  • Multiple Plan Options
  • Zero Premium Allocation Charges
  • Tax Savings^

Ref. No. KLI/22-23/E-BB/521


Browse our library of resources

- A Consumer Education Initiative series by Kotak Life

Similar Articles

ULIP Plan or Traditional Insurance Plans - Which is better?

How Does ULIP Work in India?

Worried About Running Out of Money in Retirement? 4 Tips to Avoid This Crisis

A Quick Guide to Retirement Plans

Which Is Better: ULIP or SIP?

Types of Pension Plans for Your Retirement

What are the Instruments Available for Building a Retirement Corpus?

Save Early to Keep Living Your Dreams Post Retirement

What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of ULIP?

Looking for Ways to Earn Lifetime Income in Retirement? Here Are 6 of the Top Options

Which Pension Plan Suits You best?

Can I Surrender My ULIP Policy after 2 Years?

What is the Minimum Lock-in Period for ULIP?

What are the 4 Financial Phases of Retirement? How to Budget For Each One?

What is the Difference Between EPF, VPF, and PPF? What are Their Tax Benefits?

How To Keep Your Retirement Accounts from Being Hacked?

What Happens If I Stop Paying My ULIP Policy Premium After Paying the First Premium? Will I Still Get The Return?

How To Calculate The Present Value And Future Value Of Annuities?

How is ULIP NAV calculated? How is the return calculated in ULIP?

Can NRIs Invest in ULIP Plans Offered in India?

Why Should I Invest in ULIP?

5 Common ULIP Myths That You Should Stop Believing

What are ULIPs and their Types?

Benefits of Early Retirement Planning in India

5 Reasons to Buy ULIP for a Secured Financial Future

यूलिप के 8 शुल्क

Inflation: A Key Factor to Consider into Retirement Planning

Give Your Retirement Savings A Booster-Shot with Annuities

Top 6 Flexible Benefits That ULIPs Offer

Top 4 Myths About ULIP Investments You Should Know

Retirement and Pension Plans in India- What are Your Options?

What is the difference between Life Insurance and ULIP?

ELSS vs ULIP: Which is a Better Investment?

FAQs on Taxation of ULIPs

NPS for Housewife

How has ULIP Grown Over the Last 3 years?

Annuity Plan | How to Choose the Right Annuity Plan | Kotak Life

Retirement Planning for Millennials

Why Should You Invest in NPS?

Why You Should Invest In An Annuity Plan?

What are the minimum and maximum investment in ULIP? Would the Whole Amount Insured in The ULIP Insurance be Invested in the Market?

Who Gets the Benefit After the Maturity of ULIP: The Proposer or The Life Insured?

What Happens to ULIP Premiums Paid if the Market Crashes?

Advantages of Pension Schemes and Retirement Plans

Retirement: A New Start to Life!

Difference Between Unit-Linked Insurance Plans and Non-Linked Plans

What are the Charges Levied on ULIP?

How To Make Most of Your Money After Retirement?

10 Steps to Figure Out How Much Money You Will Need After You Retire

Retirement Planning Guide: These 5 Steps Will Help You Towards a Safe, Secure and Fun Retirement

Do Pension Plans Allow any Death Benefits?

Is ULIP A Good Investment Option?

5 Reasons Why ULIP Plans are One of The Best Retirement Planning Instruments

Pros and Cons of Retirement Annuities

What Are Superannuation Benefits?

ULIP Tax Benefits: यहां निवेश करने पर मिलते हैं 5 बड़े फायदे

Why Should Retirement Planning Be on Top of Your Priority List?

Single Premium ULIP or a PPF - Which One is Better?

Types of Retirement Plans

Why Are ULIPs Called Flexible Investments?

How Quickly is Fund Switch Effected in ULIPs? Is it Done the Same Day or After a Particular Number of Days?

Different Types of ULIP Investments in India

Types of Annuity Plan | Annuity Definition - Meaning & Key Benefits

Top 4 Mistakes To Avoid While Planning For Your Retirement

How Do Annuity Options Work In NPS

Here's What Retirement Would Look Like 30 Years From Now

How Does Pension Plans in India Works?

Is ULIP a Good Option for People Above 60?

5 Steps to Gift a Smart Retirement Plan to Your Parents

Ten Signs That You're Ready to Retire

What is Premium Redirection in ULIPs Plans | ULIP Insurance Plans | Kotak Life Insurance

The Significance of Number 8,000 in Retirement Planning

यूलिप के फायदे (Benefits of ULIP in Hindi)

What are the Rules for Exit From NPS?

5 Retirement Planning Tips for a Financially Controlled Post-Employment Life

Are You Planning an Early Retirement? Here's Why Buying Annuity Plan Will Make Sense

Demystifying the Retirement Planning Process

How Is ULIP Different from Other Life Insurance Plans? Where Can I Invest - ELSS, ULIP, or PPF?

How Can I Achieve My Wealth Goal with ULIP Investment?

How can NPS help you save tax?

How Does NPS Work?

How to Build a Tax-Free Pension Income for Retirement?

What are the Chances of Losing all my Money in ULIP and How Much Return Should I Expect?

Are Annuities Great For Early Retirement?

10 Steps to Figure Out How Much Money You Will Need For Your Post Retirement Plans

What tax benefits are there on saving for retirement?

What is Fund Value in ULIP?

What is ULIP and Its Benefits?

Does Having Both ULIP Plan and Other Health Insurance Plan Make Sense?

Benefits Of Retirement & How Investments Can Help You Enjoy Them

What Are Mortality Charges In ULIP?

How Safe is it to Invest in ULIP plans?

Why ULIP Should Be a Part of Your Investment Portfolio?

Un-Retirement - Are You Ready For It?

How To Choose The Right Pension Plan?

What are the Maturity Benefits in a ULIP Plan: Fund Value Sum Assured or Only Fund Value?

At What Age Should You Start Your Retirement Planning?

Retirement Planning Guide for Working Men and Women

Is it Advisable to Withdraw the ULIP Insurance Policy After 5 Years?

What is the Death Claim Payable in the Case of ULIP?

Retirement Planning - How To Calculate Your Retirement Premium in India?

What is an Annuity Plan, and How Does Annuity Plan Work?

Is ULIP a Complex Financial Product?

Retirement planning with a systematic life insurance plan

Best Insurance Plans for a Guaranteed Monthly Income After Retirement!

Importance of Retirement Planning

What is a Retirement Plan - What are its Features?

Is it possible to live a financially independent life, even after you retire?

What are the Uses of ULIP?

How to Win at Retirement Savings?

ULIP: Can You Surrender ULIPs or Withdraw Money from It?

Importance of financial Planning for Retirement

Retirement Planning at 50? You Are Still Good to Go

Top 6 Reasons Why You Should Get A Pension Plan

What is Lock-In Period in ULIPs?

What are the things to consider before buying ULIPs?

6 Signs That You Are Not Financially Ready For An Early Retirement

Do ULIPs Give Good Returns On Investments?

Calculating a Retirement Corpus that can Support Your Lifestyle

Is the ULIP Policy Surrender Value Taxable?

How Much Corpus Does One Need for Retirement?

Which are the Best ULIP Plans in India for Children?

Is it Suggestible to Take a ULIP Plan Linked with a Term Plan?

Understanding Annuity Plans

Long Term Investment Guide for Your Retirement

What are the Differences Between ELSS ULIP and Mutual Funds?

How Can ULIPs Help You Plan for Your Child's Future?

What are the Benefits of ULIP - Explained

7 Secrets that can Make Your Post-Retirement Phase Prosperous

What Are Retirement Pension Plans?

Is It Worth Buying ULIP Plans For 10 Years?

What is Partial Withdrawal in ULIPs?

How to Choose the Best ULIP Plans to Invest in 2022?

Different Types of Retirement Schemes

What To Do With Your Retirement Accounts During An Employment Lapse?

ULIPs or Pension Plans – Which is a Better Retirement Plan?

Important Questions To Ask Yourself Before Choosing A Good Retirement Plan

Tips to invest your voluntary retirement scheme money

What is the Estimated Return Percentage on ULIP? Do Investors Get Compound Interest?

Benefits of Early Retirement Plans

Terminologies You Should Understand About Retirement Plans

Meaning of Sum Assured in a ULIP

5 Notable Investment Options for Retirees

Saving for approaching retirement with retirement insurance

Why are ULIPs One of the Best Tax Saving Instruments?

Invest for your second innings with a guaranteed savings plan

Know Why You Should Stay Invested in Your ULIP Plan

How should one decide on fund allocation within NPS?

Why Should You start Retirement Planning as soon as you start a job?

Is ULIP Better Than FD?

Top Investment Options for Retirement Planning

A Beginner's Guide to Understanding 401k Retirement Plan

Getting Close to Retirement? Six Key Retirement Planning Tips That Can Help You Retire

8 Charges in ULIP That You Must Know

What is NAV in ULIP, and How is it calculated?